Select Page

Baseball Card Mystery Packs

Mystery Trading Logo

Questions & Answers

How does this all work?

It’s simple. We have a huge collection of collectible baseball cards, ready to send out. When you place an order, we grab a random selection, package them up, and ship them out. Easy.

Will I get those cool cards in the pictures?

Maybe! When you buy a pack, we randomly select from our huge collection, so it’s likely that you won’t get the cards we’ve got in those pictures, but you might! You never know…

What's the difference between the packs?

Each pack contains a random selection of awesome cards. The differences are: the Platinum pack contains at least one Hall of Fame player, and the Gold pack contains at least one All Star player. The Silver pack may include a Hall of Famer or All Star, but it’s not guaranteed.

What kinds of cards are included in the packs?

We have a huge pool of baseball cards to pull from, all of which are in good to excellent condition. You could get classic cards from the 1980s, and the 1990s, or some from more modern eras. We have brands like Topps and Donruss, but also some weirder ones like Premier, and Score that are just as cool.

We do our best to mix up the packs to include some modern and some classics.

How does shipping work?

When you place an order for one of our Mystery Packs, we’ll randomly select the baseball cards, package them up, and ship them out via USPS as quickly as we can. We do our best to ship them out in a day or less.

We charge a flat $5.50 fee for shipping on all orders, no matter how many packs you purchase. Cool.

Do you accept returns?

We do not, sorry. All sales are final.